Broken Eve Critique/Analysis

6 min read

Deviation Actions

Violet-Foxes's avatar
By
Published:
388 Views
I'm going to critique @XxelecrtaheartxX 's character, Broken Eve. 

Here is the original bio:  creepypasta oc - broken eve by XxelectraheartxXcreepypasta oc - broken eve

First and foremost, I would like to say that I like this character better than Kali Rose. So far, this character is creepier, but the flaw is that she is still overly sexualized. Aside from that, I really like the color scheme! 
Moving on from looks, let me read her bio. I'm hoping that this character is better than Kali's, because she has real potential! 
CP/P Name: Broken Eve 
Actual Name: Eve Capel 
Nickname(s): eve
CP or Proxy: Proxy
Age: she is 21 but is still physically sixteen
D.O.B.: september first 1995
Gender: female 
Height: 5'2
Weight: 104 pounds
I like her name, it's creative.
But, of course she's a proxy. Kinda stereotypical. :bademoticon: 

I don't understand how she's physically 16, but I'll hold back on that until later. Pearl  

Lol her and I have the same birthday! Cool.
I think that the height and weight ratio are strange, but hey whatever. Pearl Emote 31 
Let's delve deeper, shall we? 
Species: ghost but can still interact with things on earth 
(For Proxies) Works for: slenderman
Friend(s): jeff, toby, masky and hoodie
Best friend(s): toby and jeff
Rival(s): jane the killer
S.O.: straight

I like the ghost idea, it's somewhat original. Sweets CHILL 
Although, as I've mentioned, the proxy thing is kinda unoriginal, and I don't understand why she has to be involved with all the well-known characters. (Steven Universe) Lars Weird Smile Emote 
Why is Jane her rival? Don't tell me she's in love with Jeff. Llama Emoji-66 (Angry) [V3] 
I don't care about her S.O. If she's straight, that's okay. 
Moooving on...

Status: girlfriend
BF/GF: Jeff the killer and toby 
Currently living: in slenders mansion 
Likes:flowers, night time, killing, cutting, satan, cutting, being 
Dislikes: the bible
Personality: cutting, bed, chips, satan, cutting, killing, stabbing, nice, shy, scared 
Catch phrase: IM GOING TO BREAK YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 

... GOD DAMN IT. Facepalm Of course she's dating Jeff. Also, is she poly-amorous? I mean hey as long as everyone is consensual towards it go right ahead. Unless this is the case, I don't see how she can be dating both Jeff and Toby. Also, YOU DON'T NEED YOUR OC TO DATE A WELL KNOWN CHARACTER IN ORDER FOR IT TO BE GOOD. LOAF INTENSIFIES 
Of course she dislikes the bible. Of course. Let me guess, she's satanic? Eye Roll 

MOTHERFUCKING HELL. DID YOU SERIOUSLY ROMANTICIZE CUTTING AGAIN? Year of Luigi You have to be fucking kidding me. Self harm is a fucking terrible thing to deal with. Stop it. 
How does bed, Satan, chips, cutting, stabbing, killing= personality? I actually had hope for this character. Personality traits are: Hot-headed, gentle, passionate, sympathetic, etc. 
The catch phrase is kinda cheesy but I don't care tbh. 

Intelligence: 10/10
Speed: 10/10 shes a ghost so
Stamina/Endurance: 10/10
Strength (upper body): 9/10
Strength (lower body): 9/10
Vision: 10/10
Smell: 0/10 
Hearing: 8/10
Reflexes: 10/10

I gotta say that I like the fact that she's intelligent. I'm always a sucker for characters with brains. I like that she's in shape. I don't understand why she can't smell, though? Maybe there's a backstory on that. This part is actually pretty okay. 

Outfit:a loose fitting blue tanktop black sport shorts and yellow socks 
Jewelry: heart earings
Tattoo(s):
Scar(s): slit throat 
Eye color:p (Lick)urpley orange 
Skin color: light tan
Fur/Hair color: pinky red 
Weapon: nothing
Abilities:telekinesis 
Other form(s):human form (on left) 
Noticeable features: her slit throat and blood out of keyes and long pretty hair 

I like the slit throat and bloody eyes. It's interesting. I don't understand how she can take a human form when she is a ghost, but maybe you mean that she goes back to her appearance before her death or whatever happened in order to scare people? Idk. I actually like the colors. The only thing I don't like is how revealing the outfit is, but that's just me. 

Family (x for deceased): her mom and dad are dead 
Past friend(s): millie and jayce they all dead
Story (put link if you want): i willl write it soon 
Pet(s):none

Ah, so there will be a story. I'll review that later. I hope it's good. As I've said, this story has potential. I'm curious as to how her friends and family died. Unfortunate that she has no pets (That's just because I love animals, I'm not saying this impacts the character). 

Fave color: purple 
Favored time of day (to kill): night 
Fave food: olives
# of eyes: two
# of legs: two
Wings?:no but sdhe can float cuz shes a ghost
Tail?:no
Fears: rapping
Strengths:her smart and fastness
Weaknesses: bed
Theme song: www.youtube.com/watch?v=wIKtgO…
Disorders: PTSD, depression, schizophrenic 
How they kill: controls victims and makes them kill themselves in various way s 

Hey, purple's my favorite color too. I agree that it's smarter to kill at night I suppose. Okay, is she afraid of rapping or being raped? Because it would be hilarious if she went to kill someone (like Dave Strider) and they started rapping at her lol. But if she is afraid of being raped, I can understand that, but wouldn't she be scared of more things? As I've said, I like her intelligence factor. The song is a nightcore song? Okay. I'll have to listen to that. Okay, so I did. I don't really like it but hey, whatever. The disorders part doesn't bug me too much, but I would like to point out the fact that disorders aren't necessary for a good character. I'd like to know what caused her PTSD, though. 
Interesting way of killing, though. 

Overall, I'd give this character a solid 5/10. It's mediocre at best. It could use some improvement, and has real potential to be an amazing character. 
© 2016 - 2024 Violet-Foxes
Comments11
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
LadyMaliah's avatar
I see you that you critique! 

Would you mind to critique my CP OC Regretful Mary? fav.me/dan2j0p
I'm interested of what do you think of her and try to help me if she has any problems ^^

Edit: Oh, sorry I just saw your profile and you said that you wanted by note, sorry I didn't see it ;-;